A Tribute to Dogs Who Spectacularly Failed Obedience School

Barkley Goodman||2 min read

Not every dog graduates top of the class. Some dogs eat the class. This is their story.

A golden retriever looking guilty next to a mess
He knows what 'stay' means. He simply disagrees with the concept.

A Tribute to Dogs Who Spectacularly Failed Obedience School

Every year, thousands of dogs enroll in obedience school. They are taught to sit, stay, come, heel, and leave it. And every year, a glorious subset of these dogs look their trainers dead in the eye and choose chaos.

This is a love letter to those dogs.

The "Sit" Refusenik

You say "sit." He looks at you. He understands. You can see comprehension flickering behind those big brown eyes. And then he lies down. Not because he's confused -- because sitting is for amateurs and he's operating on a higher plane. Or he just zooms away. Either way, you're standing there holding a treat like a fool.

The Selective Listener

This dog has perfect recall -- but only when you're holding cheese. The moment the cheese is gone, your voice becomes a gentle suggestion carried away by the wind. "Come!" you cry across the dog park. The dog makes eye contact. The dog turns around. The dog has found a puddle and the puddle is more interesting than you will ever be.

The Overachiever (at the Wrong Things)

Asked to shake? This dog will give you both paws, then roll over, then bark, then do a small interpretive dance. They haven't learned the right command. They've learned all the commands and they're performing them simultaneously like a furry one-dog orchestra.

The Social Butterfly

Some dogs go to obedience school and immediately decide it's a networking event. They don't care about "heel." They're too busy greeting every single dog in the room, sniffing things that don't need to be sniffed, and generally treating the whole experience like a cocktail party where someone forgot the cocktails.

The Graduate Who Forgot Everything

Perhaps the most devastating category: the dog who passes with flying colors, comes home, and immediately reverts to factory settings. Six weeks of training, gone. Evaporated. The diploma is on the fridge. The dog is on the counter eating butter.

And we love every single one of them. Because a dog doesn't need to be obedient to be good. They just need to be themselves -- gloriously, unapologetically, hilariously themselves.

A happy dog running through a field ignoring commands
Recall training: Week 6. Progress: None. Joy: Immeasurable.
A husky with a mischievous expression
This dog has never once done what was asked of him. He is perfect.

Stay in the loop

Sign up for our weekly pet newsletter and never miss a story.

Subscribe now